Vinyl, Concrete, or Above-Ground Pools: Which Is Best?

Are you tired of scouring the internet for unbiased information on the advantages and disadvantages of different pool types? We hear you. That’s why we’ve developed this cut-and-dry list that highlights both the pros and cons of vinyl pools, concrete pools, and above-ground pools, so you can make an informed decision on which pool best fits your wants and needs.

Pros of Vinyl Pools

  • Low initial costs: Pools with vinyl liners are constructed in a very cost-effective manner. After properly excavating the pool site, contractors build a wood, plastic or metal frame for the wall panels, pour a solid sand base, and install the vinyl liner. This process offers the lowest-cost of any inground pool.
  • Several shapes and sizes: Because of the construction process, vinyl pools can be as long, wide, and deep as your budget will allow.
  • Minimal algae growth: Vinyl material is smooth and nonporous which makes cleaning easy and keeps algae growth to a minimum.

Cons of Vinyl Pools

  • Higher overall cost: Though initial costs are minimal, the average vinyl liner only lasts between eight and 12 years and costs several thousand dollars to replace.
  • Wear and tear: Common pool chemicals cause the color of the vinyl liner to fade and wrinkles tend to appear from top to bottom over time.
  • Low-action: Pets, tree limbs, sharp objects, and substantial roughhousing can cause the thin liner to tear.


Pros of Concrete Pools

  • Unlimited sizes and shapes: Similar to vinyl pools, concrete pools can be built in any shape or size and with as much depth as budget allows.
  • Design options galore: Concrete pools allow for the installation of plaster, paint, tiles, features, amenities, designs, etc.
  • Easy integration: Concrete pools are typically used in natural settings to highlight landscaping or showcasing outdoor features

Cons of Concrete Pools

  • High lifetime costs: Concrete pools, though moderate to install, are very expensive to re-finish as the resurfacing and retiling supplies and work-hours can cost thousands.
  • High maintenance: Concrete is incredibly porous which means a substantial amount of chemicals, filtration, and overall maintenance is required to prevent algae and other damages.
  • Long installation time: It takes anywhere from two to four months to completely install a concrete pool.


Pros of Above-Ground Pools

  • Portable and temporary: Above-ground pools can be moved and installed virtually anywhere.
  • Easy maintenance: Above-ground pools don’t require regular cleaning, bleaching, and filtering because the water is always moving.
  • Size options: Available in different sizes, shapes and depths, above-ground pools can be added to any space.

Cons of Above-Ground Pools

  • Landscape damage: The weight from the water will spoil a large portion of grass.
  • Fragile material: The thin lining of above-ground pools is fairly fragile. If punctured, the pool could cause flood damages that ruin landscape, grass, and even your home.
  • Fencing or Barricades: Many above-ground pool kits don’t come with the fencing or barricading needed to keep them upright. Investing in these features is an additional, often hefty, expense.

Regardless of what type of pool you decide is best for you, properly maintaining your pool is key if you wish to enjoy it for years to come. By partnering with the maintenance pros at ASP, you can rest assured your pool is in the best hands. With years of experience and knowledgeable service, ASP is your trusted friend in the pool maintenance industry. Call us today!

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *